Have to admit I do like the bigger center protector, the way it looks as compared to the thinner one. Contacted the retailer today, told them about this, they indicated the incorrect one was sent, were sending the correct one, guessing the smaller center one. The one I have now says 2007-2009 on it. When it arrives will have to make a decision on which one to put on.
For the price I feel the manufacturer should have done a better job molding the fit in the center rather than just cutting the rubber flat. IMHO.